Google Nexus One vs. HTC Desire Comparison: Battle of the Flagship Android Phones!
With Google’s first mobile phone appearing for registration on Vodafone’s site, we thought that we would take a closer look at the features of the Nexus One and see how close it really is to the HTC Desire, the Taiwanese manufacturer’s own competition for the title of top Android device…
The results may surprise you, with the two top-end blowers sharing a lot more than Google’s open source operating system. However, with HTC’s own Sense user interface and Google’s suite of bespoke applications, there is still more than a few differences between the two.
Join us as we explore them using Omio’s mobile comparison tool!
Size:
These two phones definitely share more than a little DNA, with the Desire and the Nexus One both created by Taiwanese manufacturer HTC. They certainly look like it too, sharing an almost identical tapered rectangular form factor, burnished with metallic accents.
The front of the two is almost identical in looks, but this is where the lion’s share of physical differences lie.
Both waste very little real estate with their slender yet substantial dimensions, yet the Desire is the larger device by the slimmest of margins with a 0.2mm wider and 0.4mm deeper form factor.
When plonked side by side the difference may be negligible, and the Desire arguably uses that space well, but the Nexus One is indeed the smaller beast of the two.
Winner: Google Nexus One
————————————————————————————————————————
Weight:
The more luxurious build of the HTC Desire also adds a few pounds as the contender’s metal frame tips the scales at 135g whilst the Nexus One trips the light fantastic at a mere 130g.
The Desire is incidentally the exact same weight as the 32GB model of the iPhone 3GS so…yeah, impress someone at a party with that factoid!
Winner: Google Nexus One
————————————————————————————————————————
Screen:
Both sport identical 3.7-inch capacitive touch displays, with all of the multi-touch, proximity and tilt-sensitive sensors we’ve come to expect from high-end handsets.
The Nexus One sports four virtual menu keys beneath the display, with a navigation trackball that screams old-school BlackBerry. The HTC Desire one-ups the Google phone with physical keys flanking a whizzy optical trackpad, essentially a teeny tiny camera that tracks thumb movements.
However, it’s what appears on the screen that counts in this round, and HTC’s Sense user interface is nothing short of a revelation. A complete overhaul of Android, Sense offers quick, intuitive movements around the most frequently used features, and a genuinely enjoyable phone experience.
The Nexus One does indeed ship with the latest Eclair build of Google’s mobile operating system, making it all feel snappy and responsive, but it simply feels barren and workmanlike to use when pitted against the gorgeous menus of the Desire.
Whilst the screen is the same, the accoutrements that adorn it and aid navigation are a darn sight better on the HTC Desire. Definitely a contentious one, but we think it takes this round back from the Google-branded Nexus One.
Winner: HTC Desire
————————————————————————————————————————
Camera:
Another photo finish. The camera on both devices is a 5-megapixel affair, with autofocus, an LED flash and digital zoom. The Desire seems to streak ahead when it comes to video capture, offering a solid 30 frames per second at D1 quality. The Nexus One only has D1 recording at a minimum of 20 frames per second – how embarrassing!
Yeah, the camera is pretty much identical. Both are great, and more than functional as a smartphone add-0n.
Winner: Draw
————————————————————————————————————————
Battery:
The battery may have a longer stand-by time on the Desire (340 vs. 290 hours), but the Nexus One streaks ahead in terms of talk time, boasting a massive 10 hours on 2G versus 6 hours and 40 minutes on the HTC device. Juice in the tank, or power on the move? The choice is there…
Winner: Draw
————————————————————————————————————————
Memory:
Another sly tweak under the hood for the Desire here, as HTC cranks up their own device with an extra few MB of RAM – 572MB against the Nexus One’s 512MB.
This may not sound like a lot, but the extra few megabytes count when running multiple applications, loading software or simply keeping navigation silky smooth.
The HTC Desire does scrimp when it comes to storage however, coming out of the box with mere microSD card support for up to 32GB whilst Google are generous enough to spring for a 4GB card.
With 8GB cards doing the rounds for less than £20, it’s easy for the Desire to speed up and overtake the Nexus One’s memory banks.
Winner: HTC Desire
————————————————————————————————————————
Connectivity:
Whilst the Android powerhouses are neck and neck when it comes to the essentials – GPS, Wi-Fi, 3G and the like – the Desire is a great device when it comes to keeping in touch.
Social media widgets form a large part of HTC Sense, with ‘Peep’ giving users a handle on the Twitterverse, whilst Footprints enables geo-tagging for images and FriendStream presents a thread of recent status updates from Facebook, MySpace and others. The Nexus One uses the impressive selection of wares that Android has to offer, whilst the Desire does all that and more.
When it comes to browsing, the Google Nexus One has a great display but the Desire trumps it once again by offering support for graphically intensive sites running Adobe Flash.
Whilst Flash sites have varying degrees of functionality on the Desire, it is one of the very few phones available that can run it at all…
Winner: HTC Desire
————————————————————————————————————————
Media:
Beginning to sound like a broken record, but HTC have really tarted up the Desire to be an attractive Nexus One alternative! Dolby Mobile enhancement support makes for a richer audio experience on the HTC phone, and the addition of a stereo FM radio complete with RDS leaves the Nexus One with just static…
The Nexus One cuts through that chatter with active noise cancellation – a great addition both in terms of connectivity as well as media – and that 4GB of included memory comes in handy when taking tunes on the road.
Both have the Android Market to download applications from as well as the wonder of streaming music (thanks to Spotify), and as such media support proves another tight round for the Google-powered duo…but ultimately the Desire wins thanks to the FM radio and support for a few of the more obscure video formats.
Winner: HTC Desire
————————————————————————————————————————
Verdict:
Not really the fairest of fights when one manufacturer makes both phones… HTC gave the search giant what they wanted in the Nexus One – a market leading Android device that would showcase the best that the platform could offer.
Problem is, they just went ahead and made a phone of their own that was a little bit better. The Desire matches the Nexus One almost exactly in terms of raw hardware, and then proceeds to excel past the Google smartphone in every department. HTC Sense is just the beautiful and intuitive icing on a delicious smartphone cake…leaving the Nexus One powerful on paper but relatively soulless.
The Taiwanese manufacturer has managed to become a great company in their own right, coming out from under the shadow of their former clients to create game changing devices such as the HTC Touch Diamond.
It is little wonder that HTC are in the sights of Apple’s lawyers, with them producing phones as good as the Desire they have every chance of taking a shot at the iPhone’s dominant position…



























